TAP reading note: The LF/HF ratio does not accurately measure cardiac sympatho-vagal balance
Billman examines the assumptions needed to interpret LF/HF as cardiac sympathetic–vagal balance. LF is not a purely sympathetic signal, HF is influenced by respiration and mechanical effects, and autonomic branches do not always vary reciprocally or linearly. Similar ratios can therefore arise from different physiological processes.
Updated 2026-10-29 · Archived
The scientific content and references belong to this edition. The complete captured record is available to download below; later corrections appear in subsequent editions. Website design and interactive software are not archived here.
What the study found
Billman examines the assumptions needed to interpret LF/HF as cardiac sympathetic–vagal balance. LF is not a purely sympathetic signal, HF is influenced by respiration and mechanical effects, and autonomic branches do not always vary reciprocally or linearly. Similar ratios can therefore arise from different physiological processes.
Scope & limitations
Existing physiological experiments and mathematical arguments; no new patient cohort.
The critique targets this particular interpretation of LF/HF, not all information carried by HRV. Other measures require assessment of their own physiological basis, breathing, heart rate and recording conditions.
Population & sample
Existing physiological experiments and mathematical arguments; no new patient cohort.
Exposure or intervention
Assumptions behind LF, HF and their ratio, drawing on blockade, denervation and respiration studies.
Outcomes
Mechanisms and assumptions of autonomic interpretation; no new diagnostic-accuracy estimate.
Time frame
Different experimental and model time scales; no common follow-up.
Research funding
Not yet verified against the full text.
Research conflicts of interest
Not yet verified against the full text.
Reading scope
Full-text four assumptions, respiratory/heart-rate influences and conclusion. All cited original experiments have not been individually traced.
References
Publication record
TAP-RDN-0018 · v0.3 · English
The Allostasis Project is founded and supported by Resilio.
Record for v0.3 · Updated
Editorial responsibility: TAP Editorial Team
Editorial note
Under the editorial responsibility of the TAP Editorial Team, this publication used AI assistance for content organization and editing.
Download detailed editorial record (JSON) ↓
How responsibilities and review are recorded ↗© The Allostasis Project. All rights reserved. Reproduction or adaptation requires separate permission, subject to applicable legal exceptions.